Application Control Engine vs. Application Firewall

As cyber threats continue to evolve, today’s networks require more than just traditional security for complete protection. Two technologies have become dominant in securing digital assets: the Application Control Engine and the Application Firewall. Although both are essential for the security of digital technology, they operate on different layers and have distinct tasks. Recognizing these variances can help IT professionals avoid costly security failures and make more informed purchasing decisions.

This post will explore the fundamental differences between ACES and Application Firewalls. We will go through how each one works, the benefits and drawbacks of using one or the other, use case scenarios, and when to prefer one over the other. Whether you are securing your enterprise network or cloud-native applications, this guide will provide valuable insights.

What is an  Application Control Engine (ACE)

An Application Control Engine (ACE) module is a sophisticated Application Delivery Controller (ADC) designed to optimize the delivery, performance, and security of applications within complex network environments. Unlike conventional network security solutions that focus on IP addresses, ports, and protocols, an ACE operates at the application layer (Layer 7 of the OSI model) for more precise control over individual applications and their behavior. Traditionally linked with Cisco’s ACE module (which was discontinued in 2018), these days, modern ADCs from vendors such as F5, Citrix, or cloud providers like AWS and Azure offer similar capabilities.

Key Features of an Application Control Engine

1. Layer 4 Load Balancing: Traffic is distributed from front-end to back-end servers using transport information (e.g., IP addresses and ports) to prevent server overload, maintain a balanced load across them, and ensure service availability.
2. Layer 7 Content Switching: Allowed intelligent forwarding decisions based on Layer 7 information, such as URL or HTTP header, to offer traffic management as a service across multiple applications.
3. Server Offload: Handled SSL/TLS encryption and decryption, TCP connection management, and data caching to free up application servers from those functions and focus on application processing.
4. Application Acceleration: Used source code compression, caching, and delta encoding to reduce the size of transactions and thus improved response times for end-users.
5. Virtualised Architecture: Supported multiple virtual contexts, which allowed one ACE device to handle multiple applications with separate configurations and role-based administration.
6. Basic Security Features: Ensure the implementation of all basic security fundamentals, such as ACLs, anti-DoS measures, and some traffic filtering, but not advanced security, like a firewall.
7. Health Monitoring: Regular health checks of backend servers, achieved by rerouting traffic away from unhealthy servers, ensure that the service continues as expected.

How Does an Application Control Engine Work?

An Application Control Engine module operates between clients and servers, responsible for filtering and modifying application-level traffic. For instance, in a web application context, an ACE could inspect HTTP requests to direct them towards the appropriate server based on metrics such as server health, load, or distance. Moreover, it is also capable of rewriting URLs, managing session persistence, or even terminating SSL connections to offload cryptographic processing from the back-end servers.

What is an Application Firewall?

An Application Firewall is a security solution that monitors and controls application input and output at the application layer (Layer 7). It protects applications from threats by enforcing security policies. There are three main types of Application Firewall:

• Network-Based Application Firewalls: Situated between clients and servers to see application layer traffic.
• Host-Based Application Firewalls: Run on a server or endpoint to protect a local implementation of an application.
• Web Application Firewalls (WAFs): Firewalls built to defend web applications from universal exploits specifically.

Key Features of Application Firewall 

1. Application Layer Protection: Operates at Layer 7 of the OSI model for deep packet inspection and understanding of application-specific protocols, including HTTP and HTTPS.
2. Logging and Reporting: Generates complete logs and reports on traffic and security for compliance, incident response, and threat analysis requirements.
3. Protection Against Specific Attacks: Protect against the most common attack types on the web, including SQL injection, XSS, CSRF, file inclusion, and zero-day vulnerabilities. It also defends against threats like cookie poisoning, traffic manipulation, and URL tampering.
4. Policy-Based Control: Robust, changeable policy for enforcement to maintain security by both blocklisting and allowlisting, as well as operating in mixed mode.
5. Real-Time Threat Detection and Response: Identifies and responds to threats in real-time, including zero-day attacks, with policies that can be instantly updated, such as rate limiting during a DDoS attack.
6. Integration with Other Security Tools: Integrates with firewalls, IPS/IDS, and SIEM systems, providing comprehensive security protection and all-around defense.

How Does an Application Firewall Work?

An Application Firewall is a proxy or inline device that is interposed between HTTP traffic flows and clients, as well as application servers. It analyses request and response data against a database and responds with a rejection policy in case of a known attack. For example, a WAF may block an HTTP request that contains a SQL injection attack that attempts to access private information in the database by examining the request’s payload for evidence of such an attack. 

Application Control Engine vs. Application Firewall: Key Differences

Although ACE and Application Firewalls both handle application traffic, they serve distinct purposes, operate at different levels, and have different deployment use cases. Below is a detailed comparison:

Feature	Application Control Engine	Application Firewall
Primary Function	Application Delivery Optimisation	Application Security
OSI Layer	Layer 4 and Layer 7	Primarily Layer 7
Security Capabilities	Basic ACLs and anti-DoS measures	Advanced application-layer security, WAF features
Performance Impact	Enhances performance via load balancing, offloading	Varies, scalable for modern solutions
Traffic Handling	Distributes and accelerates traffic	Inspects traffic for security threats
Deployment	Data centres, cloud-based ADCs	On-premises, cloud, or managed services.
Scalability	Scales for high-traffic environments with virtualisation.	Scales across environments, especially cloud-based deployments.

Application Control Engine vs Application Firewall: Detailed Comparison

1. Primary Function

• Application Control Engine: The Purpose of the Application Control Engine module is to ensure the optimisation of application delivery with high performance, scalability, and availability. Just like Application Acceleration Manager, it also addresses traffic control to enhance user experience and system performance.
• Application Firewall: Application firewalls are configured to safeguard online applications from security attacks that exploit vulnerabilities. They are focused on the application’s structure and protecting the data.

2. Security Capabilities

• Application Control Engine: Provides limited security features (e.g., ACLs, anti-DoS protection). This is a protection performance-enhancing tool that requires additional security solutions.
• Application Firewall: The Application Firewall, on the other hand, is designed to provide significantly higher protection against Layer 7 attacks (e.g., SQL injection, XSS) with the added AI/ML threat detection capabilities found in more recent WAFs, such as Cloudflare and AWS WAF.

3. Traffic Management

• Application Control Engine: Delivers granular traffic management by allowing traffic to be directed across servers and prioritised so that essential applications run and bandwidth is used effectively. Moreover, it also provides high availability and scalability for your application.
• Application Firewall: Primarily concerned with traffic filtering to eliminate bad requests. Although it is capable of prioritising various types of traffic based on security policies, it does not offer the same level of load balancing or traffic optimisation as an ACE.

4. Deployment Models

• Application Control Engine: Commonly used in data centres as a network device, likely integrated with Cisco switches or routers.
• Application Firewall: Provides flexible deployment options, including hardware appliances, Cloud Services, and server plugins. Consequently, this makes AF flexible and applicable for all environments, from small organisations to large corporations.

5. Use Case Focus

• Application Control Engine:  Ideal for organisations that require visibility and control of their application use, such as BYOD or remote workers. It also helps to manage bandwidth and access control.
• Application Firewall: Ideal to protect web applications and API endpoints against targeted attacks, etc., for public-facing services like e-commerce sites.

6. Layer of Operation

• Application Control Engine: Operates at multiple OSI layers, including Layer 4 (transport) and Layer 7 (application). Consequently, this allows it to manage traffic and optimise performance holistically.
• Application Firewall: Primarily operates at Layer 7, focusing on application-specific protocols like HTTP. As a result, this makes it adept at handling web-based threats but less focused on lower-layer traffic

7. Performance vs. Security

• Application Control Engine: Focuses on performance optimisation and availability, with security as a secondary benefit. Features like SSL offload and caching directly enhance user experience.
• Application Firewall: Prioritizes security over performance. Moreover, its focus on deep packet inspection can introduce latency; however, modern implementations minimize this impact.

When to Choose Application Control Engine or Application Firewall

Use Application Control Engine When:

• You need to ensure high availability and performance for high-traffic applications.
• You require load balancing across multiple servers.
• When you want to offload SSL processing to improve server efficiency.
• You aim to consolidate application delivery infrastructure.

Note: As Cisco ACE has reached an EOL state, opt for a more advanced modern ADC, such as F5 BIG-IP, Citrix ADC, etc., or go for cloud-native solutions (AWS ALB).

Use Application Firewall When:

• You need to protect public-facing web applications from cyber threats.
• You are required to comply with security standards, such as PCI DSS.
• When real-time monitoring and logging of incoming web traffic are essential. 
• You deploy applications in cloud or hybrid environments, requiring flexible security.

3. Combining Both:

In many enterprise settings, ACE is used in conjunction with application firewalls to achieve both performance and security. An e-commerce website, for example, would’ve put an ACE in front of its servers to balance the load and provide the fastest possible experience for a customer checking out. At the same time, it would have put an AF back there to screen against SQL injection attacks on customer data.

Challenges and Considerations

When deciding between an Application Control Engine and an Application firewall, organisations must consider what their needs are: 

• Performance vs. Security: If performance is the priority, an Application Control Engine may be a more suitable option. For security-focused environments, an application firewall is essential.
• Cost: Since hardware-based ACEs could be too pricey, small organisations can opt for cloud-based WAF alternatives for cost-effectiveness. 
• Complexity: Both solutions require expertise to configure and manage effectively. Therefore, organisations must invest in training or managed services to ensure optimal performance.
• Integration: Ensure compatibility with existing infrastructure, such as cloud platforms (e.g., AWS, Azure) or content delivery networks (CDNs).

Application Control Engine (ACE) vs. Application Firewall: Pros and Cons

Feature/Aspect	Application Control Engine (ACE)	Application Firewall
Pros	Granular control over applications	AI/ML-driven real-time threat detection
	Enhances visibility into network activity	Flexible deployment: hardware, software, cloud
	Integrates with modern security platforms	Protects against SQL injection and XSS attacks
	Real-time monitoring for high-traffic scalability	Ensures compliance with security standards
Cons	Lacks advanced security; needs Web Application Firewalls (WAFs)	Inspection may cause performance latency
	Complex configuration requires expertise	Requires expert configuration and maintenance
	Limited to application-layer control	Lacks bandwidth control features like ADCs
	Misses broader network threat protection	Potential gaps without additional tools

Conclusion

Application Control Engine (ACE) and Application Firewall both serve distinct yet complementary purposes in modern network architecture. The Application Control Engine focuses on optimizing application delivery through intelligent load balancing, ensuring high availability and efficient traffic distribution. On the other hand, Application Firewalls protect applications from cyber threats by filtering traffic, enforcing security policies, and blocking malicious activities.

By deploying both technologies together, organisations can achieve a balanced approach that ensures applications are both fast and secure. For instance, an Application Control Engine can handle traffic distribution for a high-traffic e-commerce site, while a WAF protects against malicious exploits targeting customer data. As cyber threats evolve and application demands grow, understanding the strengths and limitations of these tools is essential for building a resilient digital infrastructure.

FAQs