When people talk about Soulslike games, they usually focus on the obvious: the punishing difficulty, the boss fights, the endless death loops. But that’s surface-level analysis. The real value proposition – and the reason Elden Ring became a breakout commercial juggernaut – has less to do with difficulty itself and everything to do with player agency.
In business terms, FromSoftware isn’t just selling difficult games. They’re selling a framework of decisions, and that design choice has created one of the most self-sustaining, community-driven engagement models in the industry, without subscriptions, live-service models, or monetized power creep.
Table of contents
How Soulslike Games use Agency as Retention Mechanic
Most modern live-service games manufacture retention by adding external layers of engagement: battle passes, daily objectives, exclusive cosmetic drops, and fear-of-missing-out mechanics. These systems generate short-term engagement spikes but often lead to burnout.
Soulslike games use player agency as a form of intrinsic retention. Instead of telling players what to do each day, the games provide open-ended systems where players experiment, fail, and adapt their own approaches. Builds evolve, strategies shift, and every encounter feels like a personal puzzle – one that the player chooses how to solve.
This creates long-tail engagement naturally. Players stay because they’re still optimizing, exploring, and discovering, not because they’re chasing arbitrary content drops.
Elden Ring: An Open-Ended Economy of Decisions
Nowhere is this more visible than in Elden Ring. The game doesn’t gate your progress behind artificial content schedules. Instead, it delivers a dense open world packed with:
- Multiple viable builds for every playstyle.
- An enormous number of weapons, spells, and tools that interact in complex ways.
- A near-complete absence of linear quest design or forced narrative progression.
FromSoftware essentially sells you a sandbox for personal experimentation. Every player’s experience is different because no two decision trees are alike. The result? Massively expanded replayability without any ongoing content development costs.
When someone purchases an Elden Ring Steam code, they aren’t buying 50 hours of pre-scripted content. They’re buying a self-generating gameplay loop that can easily stretch into hundreds of hours, all fueled by their own choices.
Business Model Efficiency: Single Purchase, Infinite Content
From a financial perspective, this design philosophy yields extraordinary operational efficiency:
- Low live ops cost: Minimal need for constant content drops or balance patches.
- No server infrastructure strain: Asynchronous multiplayer systems limit backend dependency.
- No monetized power progression: No balancing nightmares around paid advantages.
- High word-of-mouth marketing: Organic content generation through YouTube guides, build discussions, and Twitch streams.
In other words: Soulslike games achieve long-term, viral player engagement without the enormous ongoing development costs typical of live-service platforms.
While companies like Ubisoft or EA may spend tens of millions on seasonal content updates and battle passes, FromSoftware monetizes by simply letting players invest emotionally in self-created narratives and gameplay mastery.
Systems Design: Empowerment Over Compulsion
Technically, this approach reflects a different school of game design philosophy:
- Systemic Depth > Content Quantity: Complex, modular systems allow players to create their own goals.
- Player-Driven Pacing: Players determine their level of challenge through build variety and encounter choices.
- Consistency of Ruleset: Predictable game logic allows for player mastery, rather than artificial challenge spikes.
In short, Elden Ring and its Soulslike siblings rely on empowerment loops, not compulsion loops. The game doesn’t extract engagement through manufactured scarcity; it sustains engagement by giving players control over risk, reward, and progression.
That’s not just good design – it’s a highly scalable engagement strategy that’s rare in modern AAA development.
The Competitive Advantage
In an industry where rising development costs are forcing publishers to chase endless monetization schemes, Soulslike games design presents a different kind of revenue model:
- High up-front profitability
- Minimal live-service costs
- Massive long-term engagement
- Low risk of backlash over monetization
While many AAA publishers are trapped managing increasingly complex live-service ecosystems, FromSoftware operates with a far leaner business model that produces comparable (and often superior) revenue per title.
The result? A premium-priced product that not only sells millions of copies at launch but remains a strong seller years later, as evidenced by continued demand for Elden Ring Steam codes even long after release.
Agency Will Always Outlast Artificial Content
Soulslike games don’t sell difficulty. They sell ownership of experience. And that’s why they thrive.
By empowering players rather than manipulating them, FromSoftware has quietly built one of the most financially efficient, community-driven business models in the modern industry. And as Elden Ring continues to dominate charts with zero live-service hooks, the rest of the industry might want to stop chasing engagement metrics – and start studying systems mastery instead.
For players looking to experience that mastery firsthand, digital marketplaces like Eneba offer Elden Ring Steam codes at competitive prices, because once you’re inside the Lands Between, the only thing extracting value from you will be the game’s bosses.
